How many of the posters here who care about the dress code are under 35? The service wasattentive and polite. Not something my husband would ever put on to go to a very upscale restaurant and expect it to be okay. Seated at a table for four the other two place settings remained throughout the meal, as if there were spectral guests at the table. @conandrob240, I think he is saying that he was wearing dress shorts with a button down business shirt. You can wear a nice shirt with them but they are still shorts. The Highlawn (@thehighlawn) Instagram photos and videos thehighlawn 317 posts 12.2K followers 445 following The Highlawn Restaurant An iconic landmark revitalized & reopened. The Highlawn is rated 4.6 stars by 842 OpenTable diners. At this price point, the ambiance, service and food should be much better. From business lunches to anniversaries, our team is ready to help you plan the perfect event. Sheila O'Connell, Hotels near Thomas Edison National Historical Park, Hotels near Paddle Boating and Picnic Pavilion, Hotels near Essex County Eagle Rock September 11th Memorial, Hotels near Essex County Regatta Playground, Hotels near Jean-Jacque's Chicken & Waffles Tour, Hotels near Nia Fellowship Baptist Church, Hotels near Ahawas Achim B'nai Jacob & David, Hotels near (JFK) John F. Kennedy Intl Airport, Hotels near (EWR) Newark Liberty Intl Airport, American Restaurants for Special Occasions in West Orange, Chinese Restaurants for Lunch in West Orange. It's not the dress code itself it's the way he was treated. Great experience! Definitely a revisit. Our server, Mikela, was attentive and knowledgeable, the food excellent and the view exceptional. Great food! I only wanted to have a couple of drinks at the empty bar, in late August on hot Wednesday evening with my well dressed wife and order a couple of items from the bar menu. If you are a resident of another country or region, please select the appropriate version of Tripadvisor for your country or region in the drop-down menu. I will never return unless things change meaning that if you are going to get ripped off it at least should be an outstanding meal. The Highlawn provides three elegant dining areas, all with sweeping views of New York City. Nicely cooked crab cakes, sirloins and ribs might be what you need. Group Dining & Private Dining The Highlawn welcomes groups of all sizes for any occasion. With pricey grill selections, one wishes for some nice French Bordeaux / Burgundy. If you're a French cuisine lover, come here. They should have spoken before seating but They have a dress code posted on the website. The price does not match the quality of the cuisine or the dining experience. I ordered a rib eye with a (tiny, extra-cost) thimble of sauce; my companion ordered a petit fillet and the waiter didn't even ask if she'd like a sause with hers. The Highlawn provides elegant New American dining with sweeping views of New York City. We can surely help you find the best one according to your needs. If they have a dress code, that's one thing. What are they thinking? And it was a weeknight in mid-August at an empty bar. I had the chicken parm which was the BEST I've ever had. I happen to think Highlawn is a bit full of themselves but they do have a right to have a dress code. 1 Crest Dr, West Orange, NJ 07052 . One of my party had to sit with the corner of the next table one inch from his back. Highly recomended, it's been a while, but the place is all one can hope for. With our newly revitalized Grill Room and Bar, and elegant private event spaces, The Highlawn is ready to welcome you for any occasionfrom weddings and anniversaries to dinners and weekend brunch. We always marvel on vacation at the guys who get so upset about one out of 5 restaurants at a resort requiring pants and a collared shirt. One downside, micro greens served with steaks is not dressed. My main complaint is the host really made us feel unimportant which basically ruined the night for us and is not a mark of fine dining. I don't care how hot it is ( and it hasn't been all that hot anyway). Our daughter recently passed the bar so worked out well. Wearing shorts to a nice restaurant is as gauche as using a possessive s in your decade designations. The couple did not show for the next hour plus as the table sat vacant. Sun 11:00 am3:00 pm The waitstaff knew - it was on the wreservation and waiter #1 announced it to us - but four tables within eyeshot celebrated birthdays with a sparkler on dessert service and a rendition of Happy Birthday. We had to walk in through a toxic cloud provided by smokers, our table wasnt ready, and there was a very loud party happening upstairs. After nearly four decades managing The Highlawn, the Knowles transferred ownership to a new group of local restaurateurs, the Frungillo family, who are devoted to preserving and enhancing the spirit of this historic venue. Our drinks and appetizers were excellent, especially the crabcake andclams. Compare and book now! The filet mignon was seasoned perfectly and the crispy Brussels sprouts were delicious. The manager was gracious and apologized. There isn't a nice way to say this (or there is but I'm too tired to come up with it): grow up! They even were skimpy with the bread too! attentive and polite. Tacky. I happen to think Highlawn is a bit full of themselves but they do have a right to have a dress code. Our server, Mikela, was attentive and knowledgeable, the food excellent and the view exceptional. Kids might be excused for wearing shorts to dinner, but not adults. Given the price point here, one wonders Perhaps they knew something, or someone - they received far better service than we. So I would be pissed if my husband came out with me in shorts while I was wearing a nice dress. Our server, Arthur, was great. I wouldnt be quick to return. Who wears shorts to a nice restaurant and thinks that is okay? I would say more dressy than casual. We gave this beautiful restaurant a second chance after an awful first try. Take a look to see what's new. Bronzino great, salmon and chicken very nice. Unfortunately, not up to expectations. View great, food barely edible, service beyond terrible. great food dresses up, you dress up. First waiter introduced himself, said, "I see we're celebrating a birthday," and then vanished. Wines and beverages: list of "named" cocktails with fairly pedestrian recipes. I went on a hot night and wore dress pants and dress shirt Unreal New Years Eve event . The Highlawn is the gem of Essex County and New Jersey, a landmark venue where exceptional food and service create memories to last a lifetime. I don't have a strong opinion other than recommending some white linen pants and no socks. Women put on a short cool skirt (just as comfortable as shorts in the summer, by the way, without the American geek factor). Event though it was hot, you are just going from one air conditioned place to another. The location has incredible value as a strategic overlook, and General George Washington set up camp here during the Revolutionary War. What is the phone number of Highlawn Pavilion? If the restaurant determines that their dress code is hurting their business, they can change or go out of business. "Upscale restaurant with the best view of NYC ." (2 Tips) "views of Manhattan skyline but somehow the look and feel" (2 Tips) "Lunch on the patio with views of NYC skyline" (3 Tips) The Highland also has a magnificent view of the city which my wife loved. As Carmine Lupertazzi told Tony Soprano: a Don doesn't wear shorts. The event space hosts 15-65 guests and is the ideal setting for any gathering. The staff was really nice and Sal made us feel like old friends. 160 photos Highlawn Pavilion Eagle Rock Reservation, West Orange, NJ 07052 +1 973-731-3463 Website Improve this listing Ranked #1 of 106 Restaurants in West Orange 407 Reviews Price range: S$34 - S$135 Cuisines: French More restaurant details Tdiama West Orange 13 4 Reviewed 12 March 2022 via mobile NYC Skyline Great atmosphere! Many people come to order good hot fudge sundae, fudge and chocolate mousse. Dress up and get a picture of your party with the beautiful view of NYC as your background. 281 photos. Afterwards , the main course was served but was for a different table. Thank God there are plenty of great restaurants (not upscale, but excellent food and ambience) in NY that don't have dress codes. New York Times rated Excellent , Start Ledger 4-Stars . Eh. Highlawn Pavilion American Restaurant, Event Space, and New American Restaurant $$$ $ West Orange Save Share Tips 17 Photos 147 Menu 8.7/ 10 109 ratings Menu Dessert Menu 4 $39 Three-Course Prix Fixe Piano Room Menu 3 Dinner Menu 3Bar Menu 5 Wine List 3 Lunch Menu 4 Dessert Menu Desserts Pineapple Cre?meux Tart 9.50 But they have every right to set a dress code. Tacky. 8.7/ 10. 355 N State Rt 17, Paramus, NJ, 07652 . Unless some politically correct statist here wants to argue it is discriminatory. ), and expanding the Florentine styling of the structure. Atmosphere was festive and energetic without being crazy and chaotic. skirt steak that was cooked more than medium but still was melt in your mouth good. Apparently after giving his name for the reservation, the woman on the phone informed my fiancee that a dress code was required in the dining room, and that if we did not heed the dress code, we would not be allowed to dine. My husband wears shorts with a button-down oxford to Huntley Taverne and we have a wonderful meal and are treated like royalty. Although a nice pair of shorts with loafers wouldn't be at all out of the question. Ok, I'm calling Shenanigans on Rayo and Ilovepink - in this thread they are acting like they don't know each other but in a thread last year Rayo said he was the father of Ilovepink's son. She was nice, though. The only downside was the bar area. You and your honey pretend not to know each other and come on this board and diss the establishment and its employees. Gentleman at the next table sported a tee shirt and sneakers. Ladies were dressed in casual sundresses, dressy short outfits to cocktail type dresses. Eagle Rock Reservation, West Orange, NJ 07052 Restaurant website American $$ $$$ Dinner Lunch Main Appetizers White and Green Asparagus, Shaved Fennel, Blood Orange Vinaigrette $13.50 Classic Shrimp Cocktail, Old Bay Seasoning $16.50 It's a great place to visit for a few drinks but I wouldn't get super drunk here. The Highlawn is the gem of Essex County and New Jersey, a landmark venue where exceptional food and service create memories to last a lifetime. TueSun 5:00 pm10:00 pm Loved everything & cant wait to return to enjoy the outside patio! *We no longer except Highlawn Pavillion Gift Cards. Event though it was hot, you are just going from one air conditioned place to another. Great dining experience for me and my wife! (which these days is a standard NYC question). Its a bit loud especially at the bar. I was not asking to be seated wearing shorts at the expensive restaurant. My 4-star review represents disappointment with the noise and mayhem at this normally elegant restaurant, plus a degree of unhappiness with the limited menu. Desserts were disappointing. To communicate or ask something with the place, the Phone number is (973) 731-3463. Women should wear something nice, since you will still be in an upscale restaurant and many people will go the bar before dining. Overall, a nice evening out, but would suggest to go only occasionallyMore, service was good but food ranged from average to poor, plus my wife and i had some gastro upset next am. American, Steakhouse, Italian Hours of operation Tue-Sun 5:00 pm-10:00 pm Brunch Sun 11:00 am-3:00 pm Lunch Tue-Fri 11:30 am-3:00 pm Phone number (973) 731-3463 Website http://www.highlawn.com/ Dress code Business Casual Catering The view was fascinating , so ask for a window table. And if you were really that hot, wear a linen pant. View Our Menus. Annoying that at high prices for the steaks, an eighth of a cup of "sauce" was an extra charge. Overall 5/5 well done ! Anyway if you had pants on at least they would still have given you one of their stock jackets to wear. This sample pack comes complete with all the Royalty-Free elements you need to create your own arrangements and is perfectly suited to Hip-Hop, RnB, Funk/Soul productions. My daughters pasta was not cooked long enough and was still hard (not Al dente). The overlook upon which The Highlawn sits began as a natural trap dike formation, a glacially cut area where the Palisades Cliffs move inland to form a trap rock cliff above the Atlantic coastal plain. Great food, SUPERB service (thank you PAT! Service was very good. Food, drinks and staff is courtious and friendly. *We no longer except Highlawn Pavillion Gift Cards. Always follow her lead. HOURS OF OPERATIONTuesday - Friday: 11:30AM - 3PM (Lunch) | 3-5PM (Bar) | 5-10PM (Dinner)Saturday 5PM- 10PM (Dinner & Bar)Sunday: 11:00AM -3PM (Brunch) | 3-5PM (Bar) | 5-10PM (Dinner). Amazing service. Unfortunately, it was a rainy evening so you couldnt see the NYC skyline. I do enjoy the minor detail that these two were kicked out of HP and ended up eating at Ricalton's for some reason. Plenty of restaurants have dress codes. Seems very strange, couple that with the way Rayo characterized the employees (and no, being Italian yourself does not make it okay!) I ordered a rib eye with a (tiny, extra-cost) thimble of sauce; my companion ordered a petit fillet and the waiter didn't even ask if she'd like a sause with hers. 201-368-8844 Call Now. Thank you for an amazing anniversary night. You don't want to be out of place and will risk getting bad service. Huh, @bella. But they have every right to set a dress code. Waited 45 years to go to this restaurant. My husband, who works as a creative and never wears a suit except at weddings refuses to go to restaurants that have dress codes. Appreciated the smaller cuts for less-hearty appetites. Had not been jn a while. Are you sure you want to delete this answer? If they had said no, I would have understood. A different but delicious tuna crudo with radish and aperol spritz! Service: far below what one expects at these prices. I mean, it is BIZARRE. The Highlawn welcomes groups of all sizes for any occasion. The food was just ok, nothing to write home about. Would you be able to host a sweet 16 and if so what are the average prices. I would never wear shorts to an expensive restaurant. Want to book a hotel in New Jersey? Men wear loose pants and sandals. FAIL !!! Friday night 12-23. Dress code for just the bar area? Which is EXACTLY what happened to me. Will def return soon. Of which there are plenty. Shorts are still shorts, even if they are "dress" shorts. Men don't need a tie, but you should wear nice pants and a polo or dress shirt. 2 had the pastrami sandwich.a bit fatty for our daughter but both agreed it was delicious. Loud party upstairs until about 9 pm. The revamped Highlawn from the original Highlawn Pavillion was really great. An outstanding job. The food was ok the drinks was ok. We love the location, with the view of the city, but we would have had just as good a view from the ChitChat. No vegetables or other accompaniments for $42. Restaurant is classy, elegant, sophisticated. On the street of Crest Drive and street number is 1. The oysters were sweet, my sea bass was perfectly cooked, cocktails were well made, our waiter, Isaac, was attentive and friendly. Get Directions. West Orange, NJ. They should have spoken before seating but They have a dress code posted on the website. And my husband has some really nice shorts but they aren't for the Highlawn. Great drinks. Thank God there are plenty of great restaurants (not upscale, but excellent food and ambience) in NY that don't have dress codes. lord it's so uptight in this thread I can't breathe. @highlawnweddings Make reservations & more linktr.ee/thehighlawn Posts Reels Videos Tagged Show More Posts from thehighlawn Not that I love sparklers or singing staff, but to have noted that it was my birthday and then ignored us was quite unpleasant. Highlawn Pavilion Eagle Rock Reservation, West Orange, NJ 07052 +1 973-731-3463 Website Improve this listing Ranked #1 of 106 Restaurants in West Orange 407 Reviews Price range: $25 - $100 Cuisines: French More restaurant details P338PWmarting 1 Reviewed August 2, 2022 Dining experience Firstly, the decor and setting is quite special. Automobile enthusiasts of that period held races up the cobblestone roadway of Eagle Rock Avenue with the finish line in Eagle Rock Park, near where The Highlawn is situated today. Yelp For Businesses Write a Review Log In Sign Up Restaurants Home Services Auto Services More The Highlawn 308 reviews Claimed $$$ American (New), Seafood Edit Open 11:30 AM - 10:00 PM Are you sure you want to delete this question? I agree with sac, but in general if I'm in a self-proclaimed "fine dining" establishment dressed as a schoolboy I wouldn't expect to be taken seriously. Now, the venue atop Eagle Rock Reservation has a new owner, chef, renovated interior design, and executive team; as well as a new (yet familiar) name: Moving forward, it will simply be known as The Highlawn. Highlawn Pavilion is a turn-of-the-century Florentine-style pavilion that has been beautifully restored to European grandeur with breathtaking views of Manhattan. The bar is-as usual-quite nice and enjoyable. This was our first opportunity to visit as the reborn Pavilion and we werethrilled to see that it retains so much of what made the Highlawn so special. Had an outstanding meal for my husband's birthday. Amenities: Wheelchair accessible. thrilled to see that it retains so much of what made the Highlawn so special. Annoying that at high prices for the steaks, an eighth of a cup of "sauce" was an extra charge. End of story. Some lesser wines by the glass at about $15; OK, but not in keeping with the "gourmet" pretensions. Not for us; not for anyone else; not even a European- style bread charge on the menu. Serving Americ. The Skyline Ballroom features the most iconic panoramic views of New York Cityanywhere. Ok, I'm calling Shenanigans on Rayo and Ilovepink - in this thread they are acting like they don't know each other but in a thread last year Rayo said he was the father of Ilovepink's son. HOURS OF OPERATION Wednesday, Thursday, Sunday | 5:00 pm - 10:00 pm Bar closes one hour later 2 had the pastrami sandwich.a bit fatty for our daughter but both agreed it was delicious. Disappointed that a few things were off the menu, no specials so menu is quite limited. If you are a resident of another country or region, please select the appropriate version of Tripadvisor for your country or region in the drop-down menu. Ambience: wonderful view; decor spare but tasteful. No vegetables or other accompaniments for $42. I don't think it's THAT nice if a place that should require that kind of dress code, but if it does it does. Even at bar area, must wear Sundays best,! Highlawn Pavilion, West Orange: See 407 unbiased reviews of Highlawn Pavilion, rated 4.5 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #1 of 96 restaurants in West Orange. That's an interesting thread. I'm working on him making an exception for my birthday because I want to go to Le Bernadin, but so far no success! More about Highlawn Pavilion . The building now known as The Highlawn was constructed as a scenic overlook and refreshment stop called The Reservation. Not something my husband would ever put on to go to a very upscale restaurant and expect it to be okay. Our food was excellent, the service was professional, and the ambiance was delightful. Oysters were surprisingly hands down the BEST I have ever had in the state of NJ! Our server was Issac. A bar that is up to par with the rest. Whether you go for a Artisanal Grilled Brioche Cheese Sandwich, Chocolate Fudge Sundae In An Almond Lace Cup, Salted Butterscotch Creme Brulee, Margherita Pizza or Shrimp Tempura Highlawn Pavilion's tasty cuisine will hit the spot. Highlawn Pavilion is located in Essex County of New Jersey state. Disappointed that a few things were off the menu, no specials so menu is quite limited. OMG I feel your pain! Alcohol on Consumption, Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information. Service was very good. Highlawn Pavilion (973) 731-3463 Own this business? I hadskirt steak that was cooked more than medium but still was melt in your mouth good. king of correct score . From the moment we walked in the doors we were greeted by warm folks. The waitstaff knew - it was on the wreservation and waiter #1 announced it to us - but four tables within eyeshot celebrated birthdays with a sparkler on dessert service and a rendition of Happy Birthday. Lesson learned. The service is unmatched. This review only pertains to brunch on Sunday, 18DEC2022. 1 Crest Dr, West Orange, NJ 07052 973.731.3463. The venue, located atop Essex County Eagle Rock Reservation, has begun taking reservations for high-end celebrations, too. Thank you in advance for wearing a face covering, for adhering to social distancing protocols and for respecting the cautionary measures we have put in place for your safety and the safety of our staff. I would still dress nicely. Good valet parking and handicapped accessible. HOURS OF OPERATIONTuesday - Friday: 11:30AM - 3PM (Lunch) | 3-5PM (Bar) | 5-10PM (Dinner)Saturday 5PM- 10PM (Dinner & Bar)Sunday: 11:00AM -3PM (Brunch) | 3-5PM (Bar) | 5-10PM (Dinner). My dining companion is definitely not a "guy." The chardonnay was $18/glass. The bartender/waitress ,Sarah, was fantastic and made our visit that much better. The host knew it was a special place to us yet when I asked would not sit us next to the window because another couple decided to have a drink at the bar and he was holding this table for them. This is a great date/anniversary/special occasion place. There isn't a nice way to say this (or there is but I'm too tired to come up with it): grow up! Seating will be limited to a maximum of eight guests per table for a maximum seating time of two hours. Best ribeye. That said, if I did, and managed to be seated and have an order taken while wearing said shorts, and only THEN was asked to leave, the clueless twit managing the place wouldn't know what hit him. Second waiter took our order. A limited seating will be allocated to your party upon booking. Great food, a bit overprice which is ok because you get the amazing view ! Highlawn Pavilion is rated accordingly in the following categories by Tripadvisor travelers: Eagle Rock Reservation, West Orange, NJ 07052. End of story. For groups larger than 8, please complete this form or email events@thehighlawn.com, and a member of our team will be in touch with you shortly. It's the only way to go. I think the bartender probably didn't want to say anything and he should have if that is the policy. The gem of Essex County and New Jersey, The Highlawn is a landmark venue where exceptional food and service create memories to last a lifetime. It is pricy, but well worth it. And they told him to leave. More elaborate dishes were less successful. Yes, that is true. I have wanted to try Highlawn but have not because I have never felt like dressing up. The venue features a unique outdoor ceremony area, conveniently nestled next to the historic building at the . His singing was great but it was just so loud, and the sound system was emitting loud feedback. What's Up With The 1980's Dress Code At Highlawn P. The view is phenomenal. The elegantly arched dining room windows afford a spectacular panorama of New York City's twinkling lights and distant landings and takeoffs at Newark Liberty International Airport. Sorry. Wearing shorts to a nice restaurant is as gauche as using a possessive s in your decade designations. THE HIGHLAWN - 395 Photos & 309 Reviews - 1 Crest Dr, West Orange, NJ - Menu - Yelp Restaurants Home Services Auto Services The Highlawn 309 reviews Claimed $$$ American (New), Seafood Edit Open 11:30 AM - 10:00 PM Hours updated 2 months ago See hours See all 398 photos Write a review Add photo Save Menu Popular dishes View full menu $42.00 Raw shellfish selections are nice (and shockingly expensive) but the oysters were inappropriately displayed in the open, on ice, no sneeze guard, adjacent to the entrance where everyone passes by. The Reservation building had deteriorated to the point of becoming a safety hazard, and it was decided that the entire building should be demolished. TueFri 11:30 am3:00 pm. The breading was so tasty and had a crumb-like finish with perfectly melted cheese and the accompanying pasta was cooked just right. Food and service were absolutely amazing too. I'm taking my husband here for his birthday this weekend and was wondering if there is still a nice view in the evening? You can not reply as this discussion is Closed! Just ask. Highlawn Pavilion. The Highlawn is one of the tri-state areas most magical venues for weddings, anniversaries, bar and bat mitzvahs, birthdays, corporate events and celebrations of any kind. The food was amazing! Men in casual slacks/dress shirts to sports jackets. Yeah ultimately it's on the patron to know the policy IMO. Get quick answers from Highlawn Pavilion staff and past visitors. This sounds to me like they have a axe to grind with Highlawn or its management: But to post on a thread bashing a business together? Take your chance to taste great chocolate frappe, cappuccino or tea. No representation is made or warranty given as to their content, correctness, or usability. The service is fair at best. Desserts were nice but tiramisu cheesecake was really a small portion as was crme brle. The "Sicilian" crudo appy was a pastiche of olives, citrus sections, fish and presumably Sicilian olive oil. Highlawn Pavilion, West Orange: See 406 unbiased reviews of Highlawn Pavilion, rated 4.5 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #1 of 99 restaurants in West Orange. We all had a blast ! This is the version of our website addressed to speakers of English in the United States. My husband, who works as a creative and never wears a suit except at weddings refuses to go to restaurants that have dress codes. Zoom in to see updated info. To prevent entry to the completely deteriorated upper level, the stairway was sealed by a cement block wall. Our History Our Location The Highlawn is located atop Eagle Rock Reservation in West Orange, New Jersey. Hotels near Thomas Edison National Historical Park, Hotels near Paddle Boating and Picnic Pavilion, Hotels near Essex County Eagle Rock September 11th Memorial, Hotels near Essex County Regatta Playground, Hotels near Jean-Jacque's Chicken & Waffles Tour, Hotels near Nia Fellowship Baptist Church, Hotels near Ahawas Achim B'nai Jacob & David. We have implemented a heightened cleaning and sanitizing regimen, including continual disinfecting of our restrooms. Excellent meal, but excessively overpriced. Incredible 6 course meal great service and live entertainment! My husband wears shorts with a button-down oxford to Huntley Taverne and we have a wonderful meal and are treated like royalty. the population makes do without wearing shorts. Of course the view makes it worth it, but ambiance and food should be a bit higher all around. Gioamorim I happen to think Highlawn is a bit full of themselves but they do have a right to have a dress code.